Where in the Sam Hill is Curse of a Dark God?!

Because of so many reader requests, I think it’s time to explain.

Alas, I must report that she ran off with a no-good tramp. I’m sure she’s realized her error. Either way, I’ve formed a posse. We’re hunting her down.

That’s the true story. For those that want the boring press release that obscures the facts, you may read what follows.

The first draft of Curse of a Dark God was delivered to the editor in August of 2009, two months before Servant of a Dark God was released. That draft had some issues with a few of the story lines. These issues crept (they did not run or slouch) into the text because the author, stressed about an aggressive deadline, decided to adopt the fix-it-when-you-finish-just-get-er-done-you’ve-got-a-freaking-deadline methodology of writing.

But a book of 230,000 words is a big old momma. And if something in a beginning chapter is off, it wankers a whole heck of a lot of story that follows, much like a line of dominoes. But it’s not just one story line. This book had multiple interconnected story lines. So issues in one line rippled out into others. What this meant was that the changes that needed to be made weren’t wee things that could be dealt with in a few weeks. When the dust settled, it was clear the book required a substantial rewrite, even though the draft contained gobs of cool story.

So much for that fix-it-later experiment. You can be sure the author won’t be using that on large books again.

So the author wrote another draft of 245,000 words and delivered it in August of 2010. The story rocked. Unfortunately, there was a miscommunication on size (and there’s no use in having a drama about what was said and who was at fault and why fairies are always tiny hot chicks; despite our best efforts, life is full of bumps; the best thing to do is learn from them and move forward). The book actually needed to be in the 170,000 – 180,000 word range. Same as Servant of a Dark God.

In a 10% edit, you’re tightening a story, cutting out the fluff. In an edit designed to reduce the book by 30% or more, you’re cutting off arms and legs and removing things like livers. The story can’t survive such cuts unless the thing was obese to begin with and just needed to go on a diet. Unfortunately, Curse of a Dark God draft 3 was fairly lean, given the amount of story it contained. It was NOT a candidate for Biggest Loser.

The upshot is this third draft is going to be another major rewrite. Which means, given publishing lead times, that it’s going to take a number of months to get it on the shelves.

(fricken, ricken, grumble, frag a friggen nack)

Because I’m just starting on the outline, we don’t have a delivery date yet. As soon as we do, I’ll post it.

I apologize to all of you expectantly looking forward to the next book. When I started this series, I promised myself that I would not leave my readers hanging. I was determined that my books would come out in a timely fashion. And I have been working like a devil to do just that, but sometimes things happen. What I can promise you is that this draft will go quickly. Furthermore, I already have book 3 outlined. It should go quickly as well.

I know some of you are asking why? Why, the word limit? Aren’t there are plenty of monster books out there?

There are. In fact, about half of Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time books are roughly the length of draft 3. Publishers do sell fat books. However, the bigger the book, the harder it is to make it profitable.

First, bigger books cost more. There’s the cost of the additional paper and editing, but there’s also the extra money to ship and store.

Second, you can’t put as many copies out in the stores. You can’t because they take up more of the space that might be allotted to an individual book. So instead of being able to have stores stock four or five copies of a 120k novel, they can only stock two or three of a big old momma in that same space.

Third, bigger books cost you, dear reader, more money. Sure, the publisher might eat some of the additional costs, but some of those costs will be passed onto you.

So because of the increase in cost, the publisher needs to sell more copies; however, the limit on display space and the higher price make it harder to sell those additional copies and actually may lead to selling fewer copies.

Do you see the bind?

This doesn’t mean big books can’t be profitable. It just means that it’s not as easy. It’s a bigger risk. Part of me would want the publisher to take that risk. But the other part of me knows that slow and steady usually wins the race. Neither I nor the publisher want to gamble the long-term viability of the Dark God series. Now, if Tor was doing this all in paperback, this might not be such a big issue. But we’ve got the sweet hardback/paperback deal. And business projections have to be done in that world.

So the short of it is that we’ve run into some business limitations, and it’s going to take me a bit more time to deliver.

I wish I could announce a date at this time, but I can’t. I’ll finish up the outline for this draft and run that by the publisher around Christmas. Then it’s back to work. I promise that what you’ll get will be my best. And that’s what you want, anyway, even if it takes a bit longer to get it into your hands.

Share

Similar Posts

  • The man will not be able to attend LTUE this year, alas

    As I was walking past the circulation desk of the Logan library last week, a woman, who had been tracking my movements, turned, pointed at me, and made a loud complimentary exclamation. I know you’re thinking she said something about my fabulous looks or the animal magnetism that pours off me sometimes in uncontrollable waves. But no, she was not talking about that. She explained she had been in one of my presentations at LTUE last year and found it very helpful and was going to be at this year’s event. She asked if I was going again. 

    Up until a few days ago I was planning on it and had two new presentations prepared that I think are killer. But that was before I saw my daughter’s school basketball schedule. Life is short, and my time with my kids is even shorter, and so I will not be there to exude my extraordinary fantasy-boy kavorka upon the teeming masses. Alas.

    (What did you say? That wasn’t a kavorka I exuded?)

    Exclaiming Libaray Patron, who made my day, if you’re reading this, please accept my apologies.

    In the meantime, I’m hard at work on the thriller. I’ve finally nailed down the full premise and am moving into sketching out my scenes.

    Share
  • Awful Intent Update 11/7

    Today was awesome for writing. First, I got five hours in, and I was in flow the whole time. When you’re in flow, you’re in the scene, seeing it, smelling it, experiencing it. It’s awesome.

    Second, during my review of the first draft, I came to the final battle scene and realized I’d made it much too convoluted. Way too convoluted. When I wrote it, I thought it was great, but coming to it fresh, it was just too much. So I drew a big red line through all those pages and made a note to rewrite it. Today I got to rewrite that section plus a bunch before and after it.

    I have to say I love sheriff Hood, the female character who is teamed up with Frank. The woman is spectacular. And I love this fight scene. I don’t think I’ve ever seen or read a thriller fight scene like this one. Sorry, won’t tell you what it is (no spoilers), but I can tell you I can’t wait to get this out to readers. I’m as pleased with this as I was the snow mobile sequence in Bad Penny.

    Have a great weekend.

    Share
  • CONduit, Salt Lake City, Science Fiction and Fantasy

    Just a reminder. The CONduit convention begins on Friday. I’ll be holding a 2-hour workshop on Saturday titled “The 3 Things You Must Learn to Write Killer Stories” from 2 PM – 4 PM.

    The rest of the day on Saturday is loaded with a number of great panels featuring authors such as:

    • Michael Stackpole
    • Brandon Sanderson
    • L.E. Modesitt Jr.
    • Mette Harrison
    • Eric James Stone
    • James Dashner
    • Julie Wright
    • Dan Wells
    • Ann Chamberlin
    • And many more 

    If you look at the schedule, you’ll see sessions on

    • making your own chain mail
    • iron-age celts
    • drawing monsters
    • writing
    • jewelry making
    • filking, which is just live music, which you can join in on 
    • Ice cream social
    • A masquerade
    • And, for those of you who have been dying to learn, belly dancing (I don’t need to go to that one: my belly dances all by itself already, alas)  

    You authors, remember there’s a writers/publishers/editors social Friday night at 10 PM at the hotel bar.

    Hope to see you there!

    Share
  • Please, Mr. Brown, I recommend you undress

    Yesterday a man asked me to get naked.

    It’s true, I can do that to some people. Not wanting to pass up any chance to go native, I agreed. Yes, I know what you’re thinking–these writers think they can bend all the rules! However, the man was a dermatologist. I was there to have this annoyance on my left ear checked. When he found out my sister had some skin cancer once (it appears I should have had my skin viewed annually), that’s when he became interested in my undressing. And in my glorious state of undress, well, with a “gown” that was about as big as a dish towel, he found this thing on my leg.

    He’s like, “How long have you had that sore?”

    I said, “That old thing, I don’t know, years.”

    “Humm,” he said. He noted some odd moles that seemed to be of the happy and peaceful sort. Then he ordered a biopsy of my leg and my ear.

    Don’t know the results of the leg yet. He suspects it’s not cancer, just some random mutant growth, which may be a result of the Lizard people that control our lives and which I learned about on book tour when I was at a Barnes & Noble in Arizona telling some folks my novel was about humans being ranched, and a glassy eyed dude sitting on a nearby chair stood up and said, “Your book is true! Your book is true!”

    The biopsy of my ear demonstrated that I’m a squamous cell carcinoma head. I’m going to have a bit of Mohs micrographic surgery next Tuesday. He said we caught it very early. So I expect there to be no issues. In my mind it’s like finding a wart. True, this wart could spread. But it isn’t like they’re going to have to cut my ear off and replace it with that of a baboon.

    Now, not only did I find Reptoid mutantcy yesterday, but I think the Reptoids have invaded the Logan, Utah police department. I say this because I went to the wrong hospital yesterday. I realized my mistake and zoomed off to the right one. There’s a hundred yard stretch along the road through fields. Lo and behold, after passing through that area, a short 4 seconds, I was pulled over by a cop who gave me a $240 speeding ticket for going 51 in a 30 mph zone. Does this not suggest to you some sort of conspiracy? To me it does. He’s obviously a Reptoid sympathizer.

    Here’s more information for the curious.

    Squamous cell carcinoma

    http://www.aad.org/public/publications/pamphlets/sun_squamous.html

    Mohs micrographic surgery

    http://mohscollege.org/about/overview.php

    Baboons

    I think this clearly shows that what separates us from our primate cousins are brassieres and other articles of fine underwear. And as you can see here, they want them! Just another instance of sad human tyranny.

    Look at this woman’s face. These are the kinds of people who they feature in horror movies. I think this must be part of casting. Put the actress in a car and see what she does with a troop of baboons. She sits and screams? Perfect. What, she taught them the meaning of roadkill? No, we don’t want anyone like that.

    The Reptoids that Control our Lives and Prove My Book is True!

    They live in the hollow part of the earth. Which is probably where the 10 Tribes of Israel went as well. And when they return we’ll have all sorts of lizard people high priests and prophets. Anything’s possible.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Icke (scroll down to “Reptilians and Shape-shifting”)

    Entrances to hollow earth?

    Are they real?

    Share
  • Toots for Servant of a Dark God

    A few more sites have reviewed the book.

    Now, the fact of the matter is that not everyone will like every book. Some fantasy readers don’t think much of Tolkien. Others don’t like Brooks. Others don’t like Jordan. The list goes on. You can take the “best” writer in the world and the vast majority of the reading public will refuse to read them. These readers are not wrong. Nor are they, for the most part, meanies. They just didn’t have the kind of experience they hoped for. It could be the reader wasn’t totally in the audience for the book. It could have been the book didn’t execute well. Or a little of both. Or maybe neither–it was just not the right timing. Life can happen and affect a reading. Anyway, I found 2 more reviews. They’re positive, but they also point out issues they experienced while reading. I don’t have a hard time hearing such things (why I don’t is the subject for another post). In fact, sometimes I find them insightful. And if I begin to notice a pattern, I will often look at what they’re talking about to see if I can’t figure out what’s causing it. If it’s something in my control, then I will consider it with the next story. If not, then no harm done.

    Share

18 Comments

  1. Thanks for the update, John! And thanks for explaining the publisher’s angle. It’s very enlightening.

    Now if only someone could explain why books sold in Canada are more expensive than in the US…

  2. I also appreciate the explanation of the business problem. It’s nice to see the veil lifted from the holy mysteries of publishing sometimes. People forget that it’s a business, not a fluffy land of unicorns and fairies (hey, why ARE they always tiny hot chicks???).

  3. Thanks John. I know it is hard to get this big a tale out. It almost needs a fourth book to spread it out and keep the word count down in each book.
    Stupid publishers stuck in the whole “trillagy” mindset. Who is to say that a great story can’t be told over four, five or even ten books.

  4. The accountant in me is slavering for the day when I get to look at an actual profit and loss statement on a book project.

  5. Trillagy trillogy, I kind of like the alternate spelling. I think I’ll name my next daughter that. 🙂

    Actually, my editor wanted to avoid calling it a “trillogy” exactly for that reason. So they went with Dark God Saga so I could write more books if people went gaga. It’s me that’s wanting to get in and out in three books. And there are so many cool stories to tell that I can hardly keep myself from including them. It’s a case of Robert-Jordan-itis.

  6. I for one don’t mind the lateness, I know it will be worth the wait. Besides, I have 12 new books on my reading table waiting to be read so I’m not at a loss for something to do until I get your next one into my hands. 🙂

  7. Thanks for the explanation. I don’t mind the delay, either. It’s more important to get the book right. So, does all that extra stuff that has to be cut go into book 3?

  8. Janeited42, probably not in this case. The cut parts go to the Island of Misfit Toys or something like that.

  9. Thanks for the explanation, John. It’s a little disappointing that all that extra story won’t get into the books. But then again, maybe you can re-craft those extra bits into a novella or something along those lines.

  10. That is a possibility. We’ll see what’s left when the outline is finished on this one.

  11. Very interested in seeing how the final draft looks. The tattoos on my arms are starting to itch.

    Why the devil can’t I remember what those are called in the book?

  12. This is very sad 🙁

    I have a feeling this whole thing is an elaborate marketing scheme to get us all worked up into a lather about the new book…probably has been done for months.

    seriously though every time you have to start over on something and do some rework it gets better. because of that I am very excited about this second book – should be awesome.

    here is a great book that I read once on that very subject of rework – http://www.amazon.com/Rework-Jason-Fried/dp/0307463745 it happens to be called “Rework”. You should read it.

  13. Thank you so much for the explanation John! I loved the first book and will wait to enjoy the second.

Comments are closed.